Conservative Home's debate blogs

Advertising

  • DVD rental
  • Conservative Books
My Photo

Conservative blogs

Blog powered by Typepad

  • Tracker 2
  • Extreme Tracker

« David Davis: Vote for real change - not Blairism | Main | conservativehome.com on Radio Five »

Comments

James Hellyer

"He shares your Editor's love of trash TV (Desperate Housewives and Lost) and he listens to Jonathan Ross on Saturday mornings."

So his penchant for populist fads isn't restricted to his politics...

As for his answers to This Sun's questions, they're a bit rubbish really.

"A public sector recruitment freeze"

Doesn't address how overstaffed the public sector is - a key theme of the 2005 manifesto he wrote, and something it seems also accepted by the government.

"He wants to cut income tax in order to breathe life into the economy but the proceeds of growth will be shared with the public services"

So he wants to cut taxes, without first controlling spending, in the hope of promoting growth? Surely that means borrowing to fund tax cuts? Inflation? And the risk of the Lawson boom 'n bust redux?

"Directly-elected police chiefs, higher levels of imprisonment and more rehab places for drug addicts would characterise his law and order agenda"

The first point needs defining, the second seems very short term, and I notice his third fails to mention reclassification...

"Border controls and an audit of numbers entering and leaving Britain would be introduced"

What border controls? It's certainly a spending commitment anyway, but I'm skeptical about how you can audit illegal immigration, which by definition avoids the official record.

"As well as opposing the euro and constitution, Mr Cameron promises to fight for the return of laws governing welfare and employment to Westminster."

How exactly will he do this? France and Germany are hardly likely to give up their beloved aquis communitaire, so this sounds like either starry-eyed idealism or a cynical bid for eurosceptic votes.

Lancake

But he does support Villa - the man clearly has taste. If he supported Birmingham City on the other hand, even I would be voting for David Davis.

Elena

See? Here is the media courting that you've got to do to get anywhere in politics these days. Cameron's team have been very clever to select the Sun. Let's face it, the paper backs the winner of every election, though I doubt they influence it as much as they claim to have done in 1992.

By getting there early, Cameron can expect more positive headlines and editorials should he become Tory leader. Remember, Blair the Murdoch-lover won't be there at the next election. Can Brown control Murdoch as much as his next door neighbour?

Ted

I don't think its Tony controlling Murdoch as much as Murdoch "advising" Tony on what he can / can't do and expect Sun/Times support ... If Gordon can lecture Condeleeza Rice into near hatred for himself I'm sure he'll manage to lecture Mr Murdoch enough to guarantee Sun/Times support for the Tories.
Problem is what Murdoch would want in exchange for supporting either of the Davids?

Brie

Desperate Housewives and Lost are both Emmy Award winning shows! They're not trash TV!

Jack Stone

David Cameron shows in the interview that all this talk by some right-wingers on this site that he is some sort of lefty liberal is rubbish.
David Cameron is putting forward Conservative principles in a moderate sensible way that is and will attract people from across the political divide.
People want hope and they want change and the only way you will convince people you are going to change is with someone, young, fresh and new like DC.
You will not do it by the one more heave, carry on as before rhetoric of the Davis camp.

Editor

"Brie" is a cheese btw - "Bree" is Emmy-winning DH's star!

James Hellyer

"David Cameron shows in the interview that all this talk by some right-wingers on this site that he is some sort of lefty liberal is rubbish"

And to think I'd reserved that terms for opinions like this:

"You will not do it by the one more heave, carry on as before rhetoric of the Davis camp."

Nobody is arguing for that, Jack. Do us all a favour and buy a new record.


wasp

I think its great that he's being honest about tax and spending. Cuts in public spending are not sellable and we can't cut taxes whilst the economy is floating on a sea of debt.

Another good performance by David Cameron.

James M

Oh no a Villa fan!

They beat the mighty and true Clarets last night - the rest of the stuff is positive though from DC.

Rick

Electing Police Chiefs ? Not Civilian Police Commissioners but the actual Police Chief answerable to the Home Secretary ?

The Home Office proposes merging the South Yorkshire, North Yorkshire, West Yorkshire, and Humberside Police Forces into a Super Force covering 15.000 km2 and around 6 million citizens...........that will be a huge electorate and give the Police Chief significant political power with a bigger mandate than any MP.

James Hellyer

"I think its great that he's being honest about tax and spending. Cuts in public spending are not sellable and we can't cut taxes whilst the economy is floating on a sea of debt."

Except he said he would cut taxes, without first controlling public expenditure. So honest but stupid. Deficit financing here we come...

Rick

"Cuts in public spending are not sellable "

Then sit back and watch Gordon Brown do it !

wasp

The merging of police forces looks an awful lot like a shift to regional government. Police chiefs have been told to merge with anyone they like but not crossing regional boundaries, its similar to what is going on in the NHS etc.

Just Prescott's little plan.

tom

Is it just me or is it reassuring to know that he doesnt support man utd, arsenal or chelsea.

Mid table mediocrity but at least is not jumping on glory boy bandwagon

Henry Cook

Can I use this thread for a quick rant? What the hell were DD and DC doing at the National Television Awards getting booed on stage? We really don't need a PR disaster such as this, which could colour either of them before they even get the job. I'd like to know whose bright idea it was, and whoever it is should have a serious dressing down. What kind of a reaction did they expect from the stars of showbusiness, an industry not renowned for Conservative beliefs? Its going to be broadcast on terrestrial television to millions of people tonight, and I'm dreading having to watch it. It makes me so angry when we shoot ourselves in the foot in this kind of way. Just because the contest has been exciting, it doesn't make everyone love Tories. Aargh! Does anyone share my frustration?

Rob

"You will not do it by the one more heave, carry on as before rhetoric of the Davis camp."

It sounds to me like David Cameron is the one going for one more big heave, not looking for public spending cuts, no significant tax cutting plans? Sounds exactly like the 2005 Tory Manifesto to me. If the Tories really want to make any progress they've got to stop messing around, people want a choice, not an echo.

michael

Henry - Weren't half the audience applauding David Cameron and the other half booing David Davis? ;)

Henry Cook

Ah, now that would make sense! But it still frustrates me immensely.

James Hellyer

Maybe they were booing Billie Piper?

michael

Yer I agree. And its a timely reminder that we've still got a huge image problem to overcome.

I'm not sure Robs advocacy of spending cuts and significant tax cuts will help or be believed. Aren't people more concerned about public services, safer communities, pensions and quality of life issues?

We need to obsess about a new set of issues using a whole new lexicon, without necessarily ditching our desires to see lower taxes and effective public investment.

James Hellyer

"Aren't people more concerned about public services, safer communities, pensions and quality of life issues?"

None of which can be addressed without stinging tax increases unless you reduce public spending first. Or will the money for pensions just appear?

michael

Yes it does. What do you think I mean by effective public spending? But I avoid the word 'cut' because it plays into the old stereotype.

I also avoid talking about tax and spend as an issue in itself. It's a means to an end. The ends being public services, safer communities, pensions and quality of life issues.

James Hellyer

Nobody will believe your spending plans unless you can say where the money will come from. You cannot hide cuts - if that's what you intend - by dodging the questions that will be asked.

michael

There's no need to hide spending savings - just don't make them the centre of the campaign. As I said, a means to an end, not an end in itself.

The comments to this entry are closed.

About Conservative Home

Subscribe

  • Conservative Home's
    free eMailing List
    Enter your name and email address below:
    Name:
    Email:
    Subscribe    
    Unsubscribe