What is 'one nation conservatism'?

Anthony Howard asks this question in this morning's Times.  It's a good question to ask.  Unfortunately Mr Howard responds with a circuitous (and not particularly helpful) history lesson.

It's a good question to ask because all of the leadership candidates are claiming to be 'one nation conservatives'.  David Davis has said that he is a one nation Tory but his one nation beliefs have so far focused on improving social mobility rather than addressing chronic and intergenerational forms of poverty.  Does Sir Malcolm Rifkind believe that DD is a real one nation Tory?  Surely the Shadow Home Secretary was one of the people that Sir Malcolm had in mind when he said that the leadership race was a choice between one nation and right-wing beliefs?

Sir Malcolm Rifkind gave a whole speech on the subject on Thursday night.  Addressing one thousand people Sir Malcolm said that he joined the Conservative Party because the one nation tradition reflected his beliefs, values and aspirations.  The expression derives from Benjamin Disraeli's time.  As conservativehome.com's definition notes, Disraeli introduced the idea in his 1845 novel, Sybil.  Disraeli wrote:

"Two Nations Between Whom There Is No Intercourse And No Sympathy; Who Are As Ignorant Of Each Other's Habits, Thoughts, And Feelings, As If They Were Dwellers In Different Zones, Or Inhabitants Of Different Planets; Who Are Formed By A Different Breeding, Are Fed By Different Food, Are Ordered By Different Manners, And Are Not Governed By The Same Laws."

The material squalor of Disraeli's time has been banished to the history books but other forms of poverty have emerged - as Iain Duncan Smith and other Tories have been increasingly arguing.  Sir Malcolm's speech emphasised four objectives for a modern day one nation conservatism:

1. The eradication of residual poverty within Britain: "While the country is more prosperous than ever before and while the old class divisions have been significantly eroded, serious social problems persist and poverty can be seen in many communities."
2. An end to racial discrimination: "Only when Asian and black Britons are as likely to vote Conservative as the country as a whole will Britain be able to assume that we have achieved true racial harmony and successful integration."
3. A United Kingdom: "One Nation Tories have always found it easier to accept the devolved Britain that now exists and to work for a healthy balance between the component parts of the United Kingdom."
   
4. The fight against poverty in the developing world: "The principles of One Nation apply with equal strength to One World and we have an obligation as well as an opportunity that we must not ignore."

Few Tories could disagree with these aims but, as always, the disagreement comes in discussing solutions.  In addressing domestic poverty Sir Malcolm emphasises (1) "radical simplification and reform of the tax system to take the poorest out of tax" and (2) "increasing use of voluntary organisations rather than the state's Job Centres to match people to available employment".  These are policies Labour are unlikely to imitate but other compassionate conservatives would also emphasise family strengthening, zero tolerance policing, harm avoidance approaches to drug use and school choice.  Where does Sir Malcolm stand on those issues?

More controversial criticisms can be made of his international aspirations - which he sums up in the attractive phrase of 'One Nation in One World'.   He talks unspecifically about "global injustice" and about the "the need to see the rule of law in international relations as well as in national affairs".  Is this a reminder of his opposition to the Iraq war?  Opposition rooted in the US-UK-led coalition's failure to get legal approval from enough of the dictatorships and compromised democracies that sit on the United Nations Security Council?  Sir Malcolm's leading role in the Major Government won't help his 'One Nation in One World' credentials either.  That administration displayed pusillanimity in Srebrenica, armed repressive countries like Suharto's Indonesia and made deep cuts in overseas development expenditure. 

Comments

[Wat Tyler]

I must say I've always had real problems understanding what One Nation actually means today, other than some kind of broad "motherhood" commitment to helping the losers as well as the winners.

So there's nothing much wrong with what Sir M says by way of aspiration, but- as you say Ed- what we want to know is what we're going to do about it.

Like public services reform- he says they nedd "radical and non-doctrinaire partnership between the public and private sectors."

Well, yes...but does that for example mean putting the spending power in the hands of the customers?

He says: "The electorate are not hostile to such reforms but they will always be suspicious of a Conservative programme for involving the private sector which appears to give precedence to ideology over results. One Nation Tories have no guilt complexes about pragmatism and are much more likely to be trusted by the public."

Meaning, presumably, "Davis can't do what needs doing because he's a right-wing ideologue, whereas I can because I'm a One Nation Tory."

If only life was that simple.

[Peter Littleton]

Sir Malcolm's four points don't really seem to say an awful lot about what he is standing for.

1) He talks about the eradication of poverty. But poverty is a relative term. Clearly poverty in the UK has little relation to poverty in the Sudan, or in the Indian sub continent. Therefore, short of evening out incomes across the country it seems to me to be a very unspecific aim.

At the heart of conservatism is an acceptance of class, and indeed conservatism emabraces this, inasmuch as it creates aspiration which is a driving force in society.

Also, he doesn't mention the 'deserving and the undeserving poor'. What about those who could work but choose not to. How does society elevate these people without literally increasing handouts?

2) Why a specific commitment to ending race discrimination. Doesn't it bother him that the over 65s are far more likely to vote Tory than the 18 - 24s.

Also, social and cultural reasons may exist why ethnic minorities choose not to vote for us, beyond the colour of their skin.

3) In the US both libertarian conservatives and compassionate conservatives fully accept and endorse devolution of power locally and at State level. Positions on this are more coincidental than ideologically attached to one nationism.

4) Once again, specifics are needed in how he proposes to promote global development. Does he focus on opening up of western markets or the distribution of generous aid packages.

Also, he seems to have a lot of faith in the international rule of law. Internation law, knocked out by the UN through a complex process of political maneuvering cannot genuinely be said to have the same legitimacy as English law, debated in Parliament by elected representatives of the people.

[James Hellyer]

Sir Malcolm's basic argument seems to be that as "a One nation Conservative", he could implement radical public service reforms whereas David Davis, say, could not. The supposed reason for this is that One Nation Conservatives are pragmatic rather than ideological, and would therefore only do such things because they work, rather than because they appeal to their pet policy wonk.

The key problem with this statement is that people neither know or care about what "One Nation" Conservatism is. Like it or not, Sir Malcolm is a Conservative, and that's how he'd be seen.

The "One Nation" tag is now an empty one. It's users speak only to our political classes, and even then they do without meaning. Even by Sir Malcolm's definitions, almost everyone on the Commons could lay claim to be a One Nation Conservative.

[Blimpish]

Bang on, James - "One Nation" is political class code for "a Tory, but without the nasty Right-wing bits - so you can keep inviting me to write in the Guardian."

[Sean Fear]

"Also, social and cultural reasons may exist why ethnic minorities choose not to vote for us, beyond the colour of their skin."

It seems most unlikely that the Conservative Party would ever support a foreign policy which would appeal to most Muslim voters in this country, for example, and why should it?

[malcolm]

Why not Sean? The Conservative Party has often adopted a more evenhanded approach to the middle east than Labour and could do so again.
I wonder how many voters of whatevever religion would have their votes swayed purely by foreign policy anyway.

[Sean Fear]

Judging by some of the results from East London and Birmingham, on May 5th, I'd say that quite a lot of Muslim voters are willing to vote on the basis of foreign policy.

As it happens, I think this government has adopted a reasonably even-handed approach to the Middle East, and I would certainly not want to see our foreign policy move further in a pro-Palestinian direction.

[true religion outlet]

LO LO LO LO.....Has been very quiet, to give you love has been very quiet, you say you love like a cloud, to float freely until beautiful.....

[replica louis vuitton]

standard quilted lambskin owning a vivid Chanel Totes

[http://www.pandoracharmschristmas2013.uk.com]

http://allegiantrpg.com/index.php?title=User:QyrwvkbU#louis_vuitton_sale_463b5W4 http://savetovaliste.dzindjija.rs/index.php/User:Exgiegol#louis_vuitton_handbags_outlet_973j0J5_they_are_out_of_luck. http://zillopolis.com/drm/index.php?title=User:Jxtn5ohr#http:.2F.2Fwww.newschool.edu.2Findex.asp_504q8U2_Love_in_90_Days http://rdf.phibase.org/index.php/User:ZwdlcySw#nike_air_max_2011_374h6O8_BBRY http://savetovaliste.dzindjija.rs/index.php/User:Rhsu5lvm#retro_13_jordans_173j4Z5_BLC http://trimarktraining.com/index.php?title=User:Cpvw0ris#air_jordan_retro_303f4B4_It_seems_to_be_Jacob_Gershon http://soulstone.org/wiki/index.php/User:Kpvr3xrb#louis_vuitton_crossbody_722v2G8_in_public_office_or_on_a_pr http://ucknowledgebase.com/wiki/index.php?title=User:Mjykvzuy#air_jordan_retro_304j4U5_more_peaceful http://journalofcitizenscience.com/index.php?title=User:W4pdezqs#louis_vuitton_outlet_360s4S2_28-37 http://zillopolis.com/drm/index.php?title=User:Opyry8ga#louis_vuitton_wallet_for_men_674v1T2_but_when_buying_cotton http://ia.slis.indiana.edu/wiki/index.php/User:Em2khyeq#http:.2F.2Fwww.newschool.edu.2Findex.asp_502o8E0_If_the_issue_rem http://wiki.cuboidcrunch.com/index.php?title=User:S3cfnnzv#air_jordan_retro_933p5S3 http://wiki.foranj.com/index.php/User:SbdrorkU#louis_vuitton_handbags_outlet_368g0R0_or_savory http://documentumtips.com/index.php?title=User:Bsdnpudw#louis_vuitton_speedy_35_548l1G6_Jane_Dale http://wiki.activatedapps.com/index.php?title=User:Wxbhqnop#louis_vuitton_prices_459y0C0 http://www.babakay.net/index.php/User:KxbzpdBs#louis_vuitton_handbags_outlet_716e9U9_Edward_and_Bella_will http://2hl.org/wiki/index.php/User:Iff8mmsz#louis_vuitton_scarf_087e8Z8_As_with_several_of_the_past_cove http://onlybarnet.com/wiki/index.php?title=User:Xut0vsoo#louis_vuitton_handbags_outlet_024y3P1_at_least_6_inches http://mage-tech.org/wiki/index.php?title=User:Wlut2jml#louis_vuitton_handbags_outlet_200g7T2_By_releasing http://boim.com/wiki/index.php?title=User:Z2sctymn#nike_air_max_2011_479y6H9_your_asylum_attorney http://wiki.chelmsfordses.org.uk/index.php?title=User:Ae4igjnl#louis_vuitton_prices_599o1W4_without_panicking http://womeninit.net/wiki/index.php?title=User:TrtecoSs#louis_vuitton_speedy_35_306g4X7 http://wiki.delversdrop.com/index.php?title=User:Yikw3sjd#louis_vuitton_sneakers_936h6N9_and_helped_me http://zillopolis.com/drm/index.php?title=User:GsomomBl#louis_vuitton_outlet_808s8H5_so_a_series_of_shoes_that_are http://assassinscraft.org/wiki/User:Conccjoj#retro_13_jordans_760r0A1_An_organized http://ia.slis.indiana.edu/wiki/index.php/User:Txgi5idc#air_jordan_retro_217a5S9_In_fact http://navtejsanghera.com/wiki/index.php/User:QrtenfBe#louis_vuitton_handbags_outlet_848t3L8_A_few_years_after_he http://trimarktraining.com/index.php?title=User:AhdjnrSf#louis_vuitton_outlet_368v6K1 http://alliancewiki.info/index.php?title=User:OzlimnhU#cheap_louis_vuitton_bags_645m4C9_Disney http://shtfusa.com/index.php?title=User:GsqsikBq#louis_vuitton_sale_511c5W1_coo_to_fom_can_podce_effect http://wiki.chelmsfordses.org.uk/index.php?title=User:E3tkydzr#nike_air_max_2011_668y2N7_Wearing_them_to_be_a_happy_woman. http://ucknowledgebase.com/wiki/index.php?title=User:XtzyirSe#louis_vuitton_sneakers_836e5C0 http://wiki.bk-clan.org/index.php?title=User:JhlzrwBj#nike_air_max_2011_640j4Q3_This_is_a_favorite_storage_kit http://www.drsolutions.org/wiki/index.php/User:BkbpqsnU#retro_13_jordans_174l4S4 http://www.kaise123.com/wiki/index.php?title=User:Gsgqs0mh#louis_vuitton_sneakers_976b4N6_Mix_together_150ml http://www.50sgame.com/wiki/index.php/User:CivqloBv#louis_vuitton_handbags_outlet_320k3N7_cotton_and_rice. http://documentumtips.com/index.php?title=User:Xwvvwnld#cheap_louis_vuitton_bags_735j6K9_There_are_many_more_availab http://www.kaise123.com/wiki/index.php?title=User:RrtkmySs#louis_vuitton_scarf_518v1S9_the_following_may_contain_spoile http://soulstone.org/wiki/index.php/User:YevixqSw#nike_air_max_2011_299y8F1_instead_of_adult_food http://www.manyapedia.com/cap/User:PgexouBs#louis_vuitton_crossbody_504u5Z2_restaurants_and_gas_station http://www.sexsim.com/wiki/index.php?title=User:G2wiyrjl#louis_vuitton_mens_shoes_197j6U6_If_you_are_short_of_time_an http://wiki.cuboidcrunch.com/index.php?title=User:Yqfzz0fe#louis_vuitton_outlet_271f7G6_which_includes_an_image_galler http://www.whostudiesthestudies.com/index.php?title=User:Ivm2hzob#louis_vuitton_sneakers_173v6P1_We_are_not_consciously_aware http://www.aboutatheism.com/index.php?title=User:CzkghnrU#louis_vuitton_sneakers_221v0O5_it_says_ten_metres http://wiki.gmgg.info/index.php?title=User:Nrzunvuf#louis_vuitton_scarf_155u8O8_lavender http://www.gacarseats.com/wiki/index.php?title=User:Wd8fjzro#louis_vuitton_handbags_outlet_685b0M4_MSN_Search http://www.rad3d.ca/plastic/index.php?title=User:Zfx1fpzu#louis_vuitton_sneakers_344q4P4_._Hunter_x_Hunter http://savetovaliste.dzindjija.rs/index.php/User:Li9bqwjr#louis_vuitton_sale_884r5T8 http://www.aboutatheism.com/index.php?title=User:Mfi4arev#cheap_louis_vuitton_bags_847r5K0_Exquisite_Footwear http://navtejsanghera.com/wiki/index.php/User:SwyirnbU#louis_vuitton_speedy_35_544d7P8_000_to_.2430 http://rosswiki.com/index.php?title=User:M5dqkhqk#http:.2F.2Fwww.newschool.edu.2Findex.asp_174p7F6_demand http://shtfusa.com/index.php?title=User:KatszqSx#louis_vuitton_mens_shoes_397r9J8_Financial_CostsAfter_a_DUI http://wiki.bk-clan.org/index.php?title=User:NdafotSd#nike_air_max_2011_332k3K7_Before_starting http://soyrobot.org/index.php?title=User:M3reqjvn#louis_vuitton_mens_shoes_603l9Q2 http://ia.slis.indiana.edu/wiki/index.php/User:Lnixdjwf#louis_vuitton_sale_149x0M2_or_other_light-casting_electroni http://wiki.chelmsfordses.org.uk/index.php?title=User:Dhf8huiy#cheap_louis_vuitton_bags_825e9J5_check_around http://trimarktraining.com/index.php?title=User:P1ljitrf#louis_vuitton_prices_111o1F6_and_in_extreme_cases http://www.drsolutions.org/wiki/index.php/User:HiqsyuBu#louis_vuitton_outlet_407z1R4_P.2FE http://rosswiki.com/index.php?title=User:NdmzpgSj#http:.2F.2Fwww.newschool.edu.2Findex.asp_983h0F0_.22Therefore http://allegiantrpg.com/index.php?title=User:Surtjpdl#cheap_louis_vuitton_bags_366p9U9_THE_MOST_IMPORTANT_THING_I http://onlybarnet.com/wiki/index.php?title=User:Nn1lgfva#http:.2F.2Fwww.newschool.edu.2Findex.asp_944c0Q3_Bib_Red_Heats http://wiki.delversdrop.com/index.php?title=User:Dwa3tyrk#louis_vuitton_crossbody_064s0Y1_scaves http://zillopolis.com/drm/index.php?title=User:Zm6jaqzw#louis_vuitton_sneakers_614r2V7 http://assassinscraft.org/wiki/User:Yqm9iwku#louis_vuitton_sale_003v7D0_only_59 http://rosswiki.com/index.php?title=User:DlyherSr#louis_vuitton_crossbody_597g9C7_The_Sun http://www.manyapedia.com/cap/User:Mjm6itxw#louis_vuitton_wallet_for_men_109i1D1_and_styles. http://www.skyjon.com/wiki/index.php/User:A6ygmeww#retro_13_jordans_224q7G2_And_it_is_the_thing_that_most_wrest http://boim.com/wiki/index.php?title=User:Sincf9ip#louis_vuitton_crossbody_308v6U7_The_data_available_pin http://journalofcitizenscience.com/index.php?title=User:KcfnkkSi#louis_vuitton_handbags_outlet_603e3Z7_hotel http://womeninit.net/wiki/index.php?title=User:Awch6kaf#louis_vuitton_outlet_361l2Z4__or_just_to_pursue_their_dreams

[http://www.obreirosemfoco.com/pandora-glass-bead-a.html]

交流QQ929086309 http://futbolbaratas.com http://comprarcamisetasdefutbolbaratas.com http://camisetadefutboles.com http://webtuti.com http://www.goo.gl http://alexeflorea.com http://cvender.com http://taosnatlwatercolor.org http://louisvuittonfavorite.com http://sofiasilvaphotography.com http://taosnatlwatercolor.org http://fashionphile.com http:// http://equiposdefutbol2014.es http://hearingnotes.com http://rentmonkey.com.au http://charmsforme.com http://colobothq.org http://charmsforpandora.uk.com http://pandorachristmasgifts2013.com http://pandoracharmsclearance.com http://charmme.com.au http://speakingpixels.com http://kbco.co.uk http://literatureandlace.com http://identityaustralia.com.au http://colobothq.org http://ebuyfreerunshoes.com http://ntrvp.org http://wylwindecs.com http://kbco.co.uk http://halfcreammilk.com http://grassrootlobbying.com http://coryhenry.net http://cmvinformation.com http://wasilc.org http://bertco.net http://tranquilitysalonanspa.com/louis-vuitton/ http://ancc.us http://staidanschapel.org http://mysec.co.uk http://onlinebagcolumn.com http://maxbagsmall.com http://giftandwrap.co.uk http://charmsforpandora.uk.com http://pandoracharmsukstockists.co.uk http://smcommercial.co.uk/panel/event.asp http://impa.co.uk/ http://zoosex.co.uk http://salecharms.ca http://pandoracharmscanadacheap.com http://salecharms.ca http://pandoracharmscanadacheap.com http://pandoraradiocanada.ca http://chfchallenge.ca http://wobistal.com http://envirowestern.ca http://chfchallenge.ca http://evildeadregeneration.com http://wobistal.com http://historiccentrehouse.com http://halfcreammilk.com http://pandoracharmsclearance.com http://pandorachristmasgifts2013.com http://magicofmakingups.ca http://flightstosion.com http://rumjobs.com/