By Anthony O'Hear, Professor of Philosophy at Buckingham University, and editor of Philosophy journal.
Back in 1986, Arthur Seldon published an essay entitled ‘The Riddle of the Voucher’. The riddle was to explain why educational vouchers, having seen off all the intellectual and bureaucratic arguments against them the early 1980s, then disappeared from political view. Those who can think back that far will recall that the moral argument in favour of vouchers was that it put control of children’s education where it should belong, in the hands of their parents. They would then be able fulfil their proper role in relation to the up-bringing of their children, a source of both duty and happiness.
This is the situation of parents who send their children to independent schools (and who often make considerable sacrifices to do so), but it is not the case with the 93% of pupils in the state sector, many of whose parents simply could not contemplate independent education. For all the governmental rhetoric of choice, the 93% simply have to go where the state and its bureaucrats see fit, according to its crazily restrictive admissions codes, a situation actually high-lighted by the introduction of ‘free’ schools. For once these are over-subscribed, the rest are left only the option of the very schools the free schools were introduced to avoid.
An independent school which fails to satisfy its customers will close in short order. This is not the case with state schools, whose clientele are not customers so much as suppliants, who have to be grateful for what they get (which, to compound the insult, is actually paid for out of their taxes). Hardly surprising then, that being denied even minimum influence over their children’s education, many parents simply opt out of any interest or responsibility. Hardly surprising that too many state schools, not subject to minimal economic discipline, coast along in complacent mediocrity or worse, the damage compounded by the attempts of successive governments to regulate standards by otiose regulation and ideologically driven inspection.
Free schools represent a small, but significant step in infiltrating some real parental influence within the state sector. Despite vicious campaigning against them from the collectivist educational establishment, who see what they imply, they are proving unexpectedly popular, even (or perhaps especially) in areas of high deprivation. Emboldened by the chink of light free schools offer, it is time for the Conservative party to re-consider vouchers for its 2015 manifesto – or if that word is politically outlawed, some analogous mechanism which grants to all parents real choice over their children’s education. Put in the proper way, once parents understand how it would benefit them and their children, it ought to be a vote-winner.
No comments here, regrettably, as there's no mention of Europe in the title. Its a pity so few are interested in education and freedom, rather than just raging against Europe and Cameron.
Well, I couldn't agree more. Had Mrs T introduced education vouchers in 1985, say, she might come close to meriting the veneration subsequently heaped upon here. She didn't and nor did Major and there is little excuse for it. It's OUR money, we should decide where it is spent. Competition brings standards. You'll have noticed Eton and Westminster and Marlborough are not run by a bunch of Councillors at a shitey LEA. At the very least, make the money parents are forced to spend to avoid the State-controlled comprehensive shite-system tax-deductible.
Posted by: Pete | 01/12/2013 at 08:14 PM
I agree entirely. I have been a fan of education vouchers since I first came across the concept in the early 1980's. I haven't checked but did Milton Friedman mention the idea in "Free to Choose"?
Politically they are a difficult concept to get over. In particular if we are serious about the educational benefits, then vouchers need to be usable in fee paying schools as well so that there is a genuinely mixed economy of totally free voucher only schools, and schools charging varying amounts of supplementary fees on top of the state voucher.
Our socialist opponents would paint this as a government subsidy to rich parents who already send their children to fee paying schools.
Practical politics is likely to require banning top-up fees. Even so, they would dramatically improve the school system. We also need to allow "for profit" schools which take state pupils.
Posted by: Mohammed Amin | 01/12/2013 at 08:21 PM
This site does not render properly on my iphone 3gs - you may want to try and fix that
Posted by: wycieczki | 02/11/2013 at 08:25 AM
Doesn't appear like Facebook allows this? anymore.
Posted by: test2 | 03/18/2013 at 01:47 AM
what did u say
Posted by: info | 04/06/2013 at 05:52 PM
Your blog provided us with valuable information to work with. Each & every tips of your post are awesome. Thanks a lot for sharing. http://alltechfair.com/
Posted by: razaahsanchinawar | 04/15/2013 at 08:39 AM
Yes I agrre an interesting post.It's incredible to see the new prototipes of ecological cars that we can find on this site. technology
Posted by: sabbidash | 04/15/2013 at 12:09 PM
wow,damm good post
Posted by: xcel energy | 04/30/2013 at 08:40 AM
Athletes have actually been resorting to chiropractic adjustments for the past several years, but it was only very recently that it has been gaining considerable attention. During the 1996 Olympic Games for instance, the medical teams for the athletes already included chiropractic doctors, who treated athletes during their final preparations weeks before the opening of the games. Aside from being drug free, there are some other benefits of chiropractic to athletes. Chiropractic adjustments can guarantee that the body can keep up with lifestyle and functions of an athlete as competently as possible. Chiropractic can also speed up the recovery of common athlete injury such as lower back pains, ankle sprains, or relocated shoulders. For runners, the most common injury treated by chiropractic methods is the Iliotibial Band Syndrome, which has been proven to respond effectively to chiropractic treatments.
Posted by: fake raybans wholesale online | 05/15/2013 at 08:36 AM
mMRmFrfU http://www.Q1NLqgg4S2xq46713UPTX1.com/
mMRmFrfU
[url=http://www.Q1NLqgg4S2xq46713UPTX1.com/]mMRmFrfU[/url]
Posted by: mMRmFrfU | 05/15/2013 at 09:25 AM
I like your content, expected later on to identify much more of this type of a amazing write-up
Posted by: dark knight rises vest | 06/29/2013 at 06:37 AM
japan helps all of us by simply adding numerous exceptional functions and features. Its a unvaluable item for any supporter of japan.
Posted by: グッチキーケース | 07/25/2013 at 12:27 AM
je Félicite, il me semble c'est l'idée magnifique
horizonEn bb4arg48
Posted by: horizonEn | 08/12/2013 at 03:40 AM
Please add more good information that would help others in such good way.
Posted by: Houston Concrete | 08/12/2013 at 03:40 PM
Up-to-date information: watch Can Have A Leading role In Virtually Any Organization
Posted by: CASIO G-SHOCK | 08/13/2013 at 01:40 PM
bag Got You Straight down? We Offer The Best Solution
Posted by: シャネルポーチ | 08/13/2013 at 01:40 PM
Examples Of The Tactic That's Also Enabling bag-pros Grow
Posted by: シャネル ネックレス | 08/13/2013 at 01:40 PM
[url=http://www.g1bn39ak59h4ac55sb275v7s19v1q2eds.com/]ngomevkh[/url]
ngomevkh http://www.g1bn39ak59h4ac55sb275v7s19v1q2eds.com/
ngomevkh
Posted by: ngomevkh | 08/13/2013 at 01:48 PM
[url=http://www.gcrj5g7j204h16fx35s8ci5069j42ucqs.com/]syiiinro[/url]
syiiinro
syiiinro http://www.gcrj5g7j204h16fx35s8ci5069j42ucqs.com/
Posted by: syiiinro | 08/13/2013 at 01:48 PM
fdwmzffc
fdwmzffc http://www.gn31uoip77u4dv18165k4n76zv6s5w2vs.com/
[url=http://www.gn31uoip77u4dv18165k4n76zv6s5w2vs.com/]fdwmzffc[/url]
Posted by: fdwmzffc | 08/13/2013 at 01:48 PM
qaipvnno http://www.gl718qb9eo9u289ii7z59jwkw5386k1cs.com/
[url=http://www.gl718qb9eo9u289ii7z59jwkw5386k1cs.com/]qaipvnno[/url]
qaipvnno
Posted by: qaipvnno | 08/13/2013 at 01:48 PM
TOMS OUTLET WEBSITE
HOT PINK TOMS
TOMS CHEAP SIZE 13
TOMS OUTLET STORE ONLINE
toms for men
CHEAP TOMS ON SALE
cheap toms knockoffs
Toms Outlet Factory
shop toms shoes
Toms Shoes Recall
CHEAP REAL TOMS
toms uk shoes
Toms Shoes Wiki
CHEAP TOMS SHOES
purple toms
toms mens shoes 12
green toms
Baby Toms Shoes
tardis toms shoes
where to get toms shoes
MENS TOMS ON SALE
toms clearance
TOMS FOR CHEAP
toms shoes free shipping
toms shoes mens
where do they sell toms
toms shoes discount
the toms outlet
Thoms Shoes
mens toms
Toms Price Outlet
TOMS OUTLETS ONLINE
cheap flat shoes
pink sparkly toms
cheap toms uk
Posted by: cheap toms uk | 08/13/2013 at 02:08 PM
Louis Vuitton Handbag
Louis Vuitton Vernis
cheap authentic louis vuitton
Louis Vuitton Mens Jackets
louis vuitton sunglasses damier
red louis vuitton
Louis Vuitton Paris Bags
Louis Vuitton Belts
louis vuitton ipad case
louis vuitton beanie
cheap louis vuitton sunglasses for men
Louis Vuitton Jacket
louis vuitton jeans for men
LOUIS VUITTON BAXTER BAG
louis vuitton blackberry curve case
louis vuitton iphone 4 case
louis vuitton evidence sunglasses replica
black louis vuitton
REPLICA LOUIS VUITTON HANDBAGS UK
louis vuitton outlet authentic
Louis Vuitton Sunglasses Evidence Uk
louis vuitton india
louis vuitton speedy 35
Discount Louis Vuitton Purse
Louis Vuitton Cufflinks
LOUIS VUITTON SUNGLASSES REPLICA
Louis Vuitton Men
Posted by: Louis Vuitton Men | 08/13/2013 at 02:09 PM
JJKBFg bozwdfaeomdu, [url=http://urbrioglhkmh.com/]urbrioglhkmh[/url], [link=http://rmxhlsbtfood.com/]rmxhlsbtfood[/link], http://ajpdwnsdfcqa.com/
Posted by: gwisut | 08/13/2013 at 02:12 PM
Stivaletti Hogan
Hogan Outlet
HOGAN CATANIA
outlet hogan marche
HOGAN OUTLET ROMA
HOGAN FEMMINILI
SCARPE UOMO HOGAN
Hogan Kids
HOGAN MILANO
comprare hogan online
outlet roma hogan
cerco scarpe hogan
negozi hogan milano
scarpe hogan scontate
Hogan Traditional
HOGAN ATTRACTIVE
hogan bambino
prezzi scarpe hogan
BALLERINE HOGAN
interactive hogan
hogan outlet serravalle
Scarpe Hogan Bambina
HOGAN OUTLET MARCHE
Posted by: HOGAN OUTLET MARCHE | 08/13/2013 at 02:29 PM