Stephan Shakespeare: The public has yet to decide if it wants a more regulated capitalism
British and American capitalism used to be solidly paired together and contrasted against the European version: it was the Anglo-American model (lower tax, less regulation, more energetically competitive) versus the Social-Democratic model (cooperative and unthreatening). In the last few decades, within the embrace of the EU and its regulatory instincts, British business has evolved into something perhaps more socialised and humane - though some would also describe it as too bureaucratised, too safe, not dynamic enough. The movement hasn't all been one-way; notably Germany has edged a little in our direction.
A deep financial crisis such as the one in which we're still stuck is often the catalyst for a significant change in attitudes. Are we now witnessing a decisive shift against unequal wealth? We've seen near-violent reaction towards people who have received hefty bonuses while the majority of the nation felt it was suffering, with politicians on all sides rushing in to fan the flames of outrage. We appear to be in an anti-business mood, even though we're also desperate for economic growth. Are we now ready to turn our backs decisively on American capitalism in preference for a softer EU variety?
There's good news for campaigners: the issue is unsettled and the public is open for influence. As part of our polling for Thursday's YouGov-Cambridge Symposium* on 'Public opinion, economic governance and the future of Europe', we asked about attitudes to regulation, pay, and bonuses. We tried to locate the public preference on a spectrum from a highly regulated to a more self-determined course for companies, and found little consensus. Only on one issue did we get majority agreement (and then only narrowly, 53%): that bonuses should be more tightly controlled. But 32% want companies to 'act independently' to do what is 'best for business' against 30% who said there should be tighter regulations to ensure they 'take account of their wider impact', with 15% on a middle position; and nearly a quarter saying 'don't know'.
*By the way, if you'd like to come to the YouGov-Cambridge Symposium, at the British Academy in London, from 9 til 6 this Thursday, there are still a few places left. Email email@example.com. Speakers include: Rt Hon Frances Maude, Minister for the Cabinet Office; Rt Hon Alistair Darling, Labour MP and former UK Chancellor of the Exchequer; John Humphrys, Presenter, BBC Radio 4 Today Programme; Polly Toynbee, Guardian columnist; Sir Roger Carr, President, CBI; Jim O’Neill, Chairman, Goldman Sachs Asset Management and author of the BRIC term; Sir Win Bischoff, Chairman, Lloyds Banking Group plc; Lord Wood, Senior Advisor to Ed Miliband and Shadow Cabinet Minister Without Portfolio; Rt Hon John Redwood, Conservative MP and Chairman of the Economic Competitiveness Policy Group; Rt Hon Bernard Jenkin, Conservative MP and Chairman, House of Commons Public Administration Select Committee; Lord Glasman, Labour peer; Declan Ganley, Chairman and CEO, Ganley Group of Companies; Alex Ellis, Director of Strategy, UK Foreign and Commonwealth Office; Georges Ugeux, CEO of Galileo Global Advisors and former Vice President of the New York Stock Exchange; Louise Cooper, Senior Markets Analyst, BGC; Professor Andrew Gamble, Head of Politics and International Studies, Cambridge University; Dr Linda Yueh, Economics Editor, Bloomberg TV & Fellow in Economics, Oxford University, and others…