Richard Pater: Who will be in Israel’s Next Government?
Richard Pater is Director of BICOM [British Israel Communications and Research Centre]. Follow Richard on Twitter.
In all likelihood, Benjamin Netanyahu’s Likud-Israel Beteinu party will win next Tuesday’s election and be asked to form the next government. The left and centre left parties have failed to unite behind a realistic prime ministerial candidate. Furthermore, due to the dynamic of the Israeli political system, even if the left and right blocks come out close to even, the ultra-orthodox parties will once again hold the balance of power, and inevitably endorse Netanyahu as Prime Minister when they are invited to the President’s residence to make their recommendation. However, Likud-Beteinu may not have it all their way.
This is because the vote could be closer than most of the opinion polls have been predicting, as around 18% (21 seats out of 120) are still undecided. Following the results, the real (fun) horse trading begins. With Netanyahu’s Likud–Beteinu joint list expected to be the largest party, it will receive upward of 35 seats, (although not as much as the 42 the joint list has today or the prediction of 45+ when the merger was announced), and will need thus to bring in coalition partners to pass the golden 61 threshold.
The Prime Minister has two broad choices - to remain with his ‘natural partners’: the ultra –orthodox parties and the pro-settler right wing. Or to veer to the left, and peel off one or two centrist parties to give the government more balance. He could of course choose a third option by blurring the above distinction and accommodate competing interests in the same government. On top of the consternation of the parties is an added layer of intrigue; who will take the most important jobs within the Cabinet?
One person now unlikely to be in it is the Prime Minister’s partner and leader of Yisrael Beteinu - Avigdor Lieberman. When their merger was announced the latter was apparently offered his choice of the three most senior cabinet positions: Foreign Affairs (in which he served in the outgoing government), Defence and Finance. Since that deal, Lieberman has resigned his post as Foreign Minister as he is facing charges on breach of trust. At this stage, he cannot serve as a Minister, but until he is indicted he can continue to serve as a member of parliament. He will most likely take a role as head of the foreign affairs and defence committee in parliament. Here are some of the characters who could feature in the next government.
The favourite for the Minister of Defence is a former chief of staff of the Defence forces and the outgoing Minister for Strategic Affairs, Moshe ‘Boogie’ Ya’alon. Ya’alon is a security hawk, but a pragmatist. He talks of supporting the Oslo peace process at the time he was a commander in the West Bank. However, he grew cynical as he watched the strengthening of terror cells. Ya’alon may feel the envy of other senior Likud figures who will one day compete for the party leadership and recognise Ya’alon as a genuine contender.
If Netanyahu does lean centre (and they pass the electoral threshold) he may look to appoint Kadima chairman - and another former chief of staff - Shaul Mofaz as Minister of Defence. A month ago this would have been considered a joke (some still do). The Kadima party has been decimated, but a well-crafted positive campaign has led to a mini-revival in the polls. The current Defence Minister Ehud Barak remains an outside bet to remain in the post, even though he announced his retirement from politics in December. A careful reading of his statement suggests he has left room to be called back into the cabinet as a professional minister. His most significant achievement in the last government was building exceptionally good relations with US Defence officials. It will be crucial that the new defence minister or another senior minister takes on the role of close coordination with Washington.
Gidon Saar, the outgoing Minister for Education is another potential future Likud leader and even prime minister. He, too, will expect a promotion after finishing in top place in the Likud primaries two elections running. As Minister for Education, he presided over a dramatic improvement in Israel’s international ranking in maths and science. He could potentially serve as Israel’s next Foreign Minister or Finance Minister.
Of course, the person who most wants to be Foreign Minister (her old job in the Olmert government) is Tzipi Livni. She has said though she would only take the position if the government’s guidelines matched her own ideological commitment rigorously to pursue final status negotiations with the Palestinians. Her inclusion would seem at odds with that of the Jewish Home party.
The Finance portfolio is considered by some a poisoned chalice. There is growing concern that the incumbent government will face a large budget deficit. Aspiring politicians are rarely keen to be directly associated with tax hikes and cuts in expenditure. However the seniority and high profile of the post means it is difficult to say no. There is one theory that Yuval Steinitz will continue in this capacity for another year. At which time Ruby Rivlin, the Speaker of the Knessetm hopes to be elected President. Steinitz could then take over as Speaker - and a clean, vindicated Lieberman take his place and returns to the cabinet.
Though we will of course need to wait till next Wednesday and see exactly where the votes fall to have a better understanding of who will form the government.
Read Fathom: For a Deeper Understanding of Israel and the Region