The twenty-one Conservative MPs who voted to keep the 'John Lewis list'

1. David Amess
2. James Arbuthnot
3. Henry Bellingham
4. Brian Binley
5. Sir John Butterfill
6. Christopher Chope
7. John Greenway
8. Gerald Howarth
9. Bernard Jenkin
10. Julie Kirkbride
11. Eleanor Laing
12. Anne McIntosh
13. Andrew Mackay
14. Andrew Rosindell
15. Hugo Swire
16. Sir Peter Tapsell
17. Angela Watkinson
18. Ann Widdecombe
19. David Wilshire
20. Lady Ann Winterton
21. Sir Nicholas Winterton.

RedBox lists all of the Labour and other MPs who also voted to keep the second home allowance, as it is properly called.

Mr Cameron has rightly attacked Gordon Brown for not leading on this issue but it is disappointing that three four frontbenchers/ whips (Gerald Howarth, Andrew Rosindell and Angela Watkinson and Eleanor Laing) and most notably of all Andrew Mackay, the key fixer within his private office, ignored the call he made at the MPs' recent away weekend for the party to be most reformist when it came to parliamentary allowances.